{"id":10730,"date":"2026-05-17T09:51:35","date_gmt":"2026-05-17T04:21:35","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/learningandcreativity.com\/silhouette\/?p=10730"},"modified":"2026-05-17T09:52:48","modified_gmt":"2026-05-17T04:22:48","slug":"baring-kabir-sumans-soul-a-review-of-bare-voice","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/learningandcreativity.com\/silhouette\/baring-kabir-sumans-soul-a-review-of-bare-voice\/","title":{"rendered":"Baring Kabir Suman\u2019s Soul \u2013 A Review of Bare Voice"},"content":{"rendered":"
\"A

A mosaic of Suman’s life<\/p><\/div>\n

In Jaideep Varma\u2019s documentary film Bare Voice, <\/em>not only does the ageing singer, composer, lyricist Kabir Suman sing in his bare voice, but he also bares his soul to Jaideep and his camera and by proxy to his viewers and to posterity. Suman is candid about the fact that the first song he penned was a fake Rabindra Sangeet, he is candid about his first meeting with Maya Angelou in USA, his first live show in Calcutta and the women who came into his life. He records for posterity how he was pushed into the Naxalite version of Communism by the cold metallic nozzle of a pistol and how he fell out of Communist ideals by the sight of the endless rows of \u2018Unbckannt\u2019 (meaning Unknown) graves on the other side of the crumbled Berlin Wall. He shares anecdotes of his days as Lok Sabha M.P, he tells us why he abandoned his \u2018\u09aa\u09c8\u09a4\u09c7’ (Brahminical holy thread) and embraced Islam and he laments his return to his roots from the \u2018new world\u2019 holding promise for his creativity to blossom.<\/p>\n

As Suman speaks, he relives those moments in his life. He is overpowered by emotions that he had felt decades back and the emotions pour out through his expressions, his voice, his entire body.<\/p>\n

Suman does not play to the camera as he speaks. He simply relives his long, chequered, colourful life through his reminiscences. The camera is the catalyst that provokes him to look back and perhaps re- examine.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

\"Suman

Suman down his memory lane<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

Jaideep Varma, on his part, has heightened the dramatic moments through the relentless camera gaze slowly fading into the black. He has used archival footage as a counterpoint to Suman\u2019s dramatic retelling. In telling the story of Suman\u2019s life and the stories behind his songs, Varma has stuck to a linear chronology, starting from baby Suman absorbing Bismillah Khan\u2019s shehnai through the thick towel he was wrapped in, to his falling out of an elite English medium school and taking admission in a Bengali medium school where he learnt all the good things of life, to his first audition at AIR, his first visit to France where he encounters Bob Dylan like brandy in an empty stomach, his stay in USA and subsequent return to his city- right up to the present times where he is experimenting with Bangla kheyal.\u00a0 The story is put together with Suman\u2019s own reminiscences, interspersed with comments from co-musicians, music critics and cultural commentators. Shantanu Moitra says, \u201chere is one man who can enter the Hall of Fame as a lyricist, as a composer and as a singer. But why have we forgotten him today? Where did we go wrong or where did he go wrong?\u201d<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

\"Suman

Suman singing Bangla Khayal<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

With that question we enter the story of Suman\u2019s life and his music. Suman is born in a land where ideas of nationalism have taken roots; where stalwarts of Bengal Renaissance have rediscovered our roots. He speaks in a language that has given the nation its national anthem and national song. This is a place where not just the Pancha Kavi,<\/em> but all the stalwarts of the Bengal Renaissance have composed songs \u2013 be it Raja Ram Mohan Roy or Chittaranjan Das. Early in the film Suman hums a Rabindra Sangeet \u201c\u098f \u0995\u09bf \u09b8\u09a4\u09cd\u09af \u09b8\u0995\u09b2\u0987 \u09b8\u09a4\u09cd\u09af, \u09b9\u09c7 \u0986\u09ae\u09be\u09b0 \u099a\u09bf\u09b0\u09ad\u0995\u09cd\u09a4\u201d (Is it all true, O my ever admirer) and says that one can spend a lifetime singing only Rabindra Sangeet.\u00a0 A little later he says that we are cursed to have a Rabindranath among us. We cannot get out of his shadow. As the nation is burning and a war is waging and refugees are pouring from across the border, All India Radio is continuing to broadcast songs of love and longing \u2013 songs that have no relevance to the times we are living in.<\/p>\n

Suman picks up his pen and writes about common people in straightforward and almost colloquial words. His songs are not rousing revolutionary songs like those of Salil Chowdhury. His songs are not sloppy with cliched metaphors. The metaphors are fresh and relatable.<\/p>\n

\u0997\u09be\u09a8 \u09a4\u09c1\u09ae\u09bf \u09b9\u0993 \u0997\u09b0\u09ae\u0995\u09be\u09b2\u09c7\u09b0\u00a0\u09b8\u09a8\u09cd\u09a7\u09cd\u09af\u09c7\u09ac\u09c7\u09b2\u09be\u09b0\u00a0\u09b9\u09be\u0993\u09df\u09be
\n\u0985\u09a8\u09c7\u0995 \u09aa\u09c1\u09dc\u09c7 \u09af\u09be\u0993\u09df\u09be\u09b0 \u09aa\u09b0\u09c7 \u0996\u09be\u09a8\u09bf\u0995 \u09ac\u09c7\u0981\u099a\u09c7 \u09af\u09be\u0993\u09df\u09be<\/p>\n

(Song, you are an evening breeze after a hot summer day
\nA fresh breath of life after the burn out of the day)<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

\"The

The mad man round the street corner in the song Pagol<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

Suman\u2019s songs are not about the exotic. They are about the commonplace – the teenaged rickshaw puller, the mad man at the street corner, the unknown flute seller who walks along the lane on a rainy day and his songs are about his bustling city Calcutta. Calcutta is the city he grew up in and returned to again and again from his visits to the West.<\/p>\n

\u098f\u0987 \u09b6\u09b9\u09b0 \u099c\u09be\u09a8\u09c7 \u0986\u09ae\u09be\u09b0 \u09aa\u09cd\u09b0\u09a5\u09ae \u09b8\u09ac \u0995\u09bf\u099b\u09c1
\n\u09aa\u09be\u09b2\u09a4\u09c7\u00a0\u099a\u09be\u0987 \u09af\u09a4 \u09b8\u09c7 \u0986\u09b8\u09c7 \u0986\u09ae\u09be\u09b0 \u09aa\u09bf\u099b\u09c1 \u09aa\u09bf\u099b\u09c1<\/p>\n

(This city knows all my first acts
\nThe more I run away the more it follows my tracks)<\/p>\n

As we watch these songs playing out in Bare Voice<\/em>, we thank his mother Uma for putting him in a Bengali school. Suman would probably never have had such a robust command over his language if he studied in an elite English medium school.<\/p>\n

Sudipto Chatterjee says in the prelude of Bare Voice<\/em> \u201cIf a great artist shows up on a cultural horizon, there are two things that he definitely does. One, he produces a volume and two, he exhausts a language.\u201d<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

\"Suman

Suman trying out the table organ at HMV studio<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

Suman is not a messiah who has come down to save the world. He is not a pied piper who takes his followers wherever he goes. He stands alone and firm. He is a chronicler of his times \u2013 an observer sometimes bemused, sometimes angry, always alert. One whole generation has grown up listening to \u2018\u0986\u09ae\u09be\u09a6\u09c7\u09b0\u0987 \u099c\u09a8\u09cd\u09af\u2019 (It is all for us), \u2018\u09a4\u09cb\u09ae\u09be\u0995\u09c7 \u099a\u09be\u0987\u2019(All I need is you), \u2018\u09aa\u09c7\u099f\u0995\u09be\u099f\u09bf \u099a\u09be\u0981\u09a6\u09bf\u09af\u09bc\u09be\u09b2\u2019 (The moon shaped kite) or \u2018\u0993 \u0997\u09be\u09a8\u0993\u09df\u09be\u09b2\u09be\u2019 (Peddler of songs).<\/p>\n

Jaideep Varma has visualized these songs with his loving yet scathing, well framed yet unromantic lens. His camera is observant, unhurried and not eager to please the \u2018reels generation\u2019. In the song \u2018\u09aa\u09c7\u099f\u0995\u09be\u099f\u09bf \u099a\u09be\u0981\u09a6\u09bf\u09af\u09bc\u09be\u09b2\u2019 he has kept his camera just behind the paddle of the cycle rickshaw. For the entire duration of the song, we see a pair of cracked feet wearing worn out \u2018hawai chappals\u2019 pushing the paddles. Jaideep\u2019s view of Calcutta is not a tourist\u2019s superficial view. It is a familiar view of an insider. Jaideep does not wear his technical proficiency on his arm. It is quietly integrated in the body of the film. His attention to details and the depth of his research shows in the animated graphics, in the in-between texts to bridge the sequences, in the mosaic of various facets of Suman\u2019s life.<\/p>\n

 <\/p>\n

\"PVisualization

PVisualization of the song Petkati Chabial<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

The much-awaited line \u2018\u0997\u09dc\u09bf\u09df\u09be\u09b9\u09be\u099f\u09be\u09b0 \u09ae\u09cb\u09dc \u09ae\u09bf\u09a8\u09bf \u09ae\u09bf\u09a8\u09bf \u09ac\u09be\u09b8 \u09ac\u09be\u09b8\u2019\u00a0(The Gariahat crossing\/ Mini buses racing) comes at 56 min 29 sec. A song released in 1992 springs back to life with redoubled energy with visuals captured almost 25 years after the original release of the song. The song takes up 6 minutes of screen time, with comments by Sudipto Chatterjee, Shantanu Moitra and Suman himself, skilfully interspersed in between the lyrics. It leaves one breathless and hungry for more.<\/p>\n

Close at heels follows Suman\u2019s signature song \u2018\u09a4\u09cb\u09ae\u09be\u0995\u09c7 \u099a\u09be\u0987\u2019. As a prelude to the song Suman recounts how the lyrics came to him as longing for a woman and suddenly spinned off to a new level, leaving the woman behind. Suman says, \u201cAnd now the girl was no more there. Just Kolkata.\u201d Jaideep\u2019s camera follows a girl in slow motion, then cranes up to give us a bird\u2019s eye view of Kolkata. Suman\u2019s bare voice singing merges with the original sound track released in 1992 \u2013 and then back to his bare voice singing, which merges with the 30th<\/sup> anniversary concert in celebration of the song. A plaintive solo song of longing suddenly becomes a chorus.<\/p>\n

\u2018\u09a4\u09bf\u09a8\u09bf \u09ac\u09c3\u09a6\u09cd\u09a7 \u09b9\u09b2\u09c7\u09a8\u2019\u00a0(He grows old) is a song dedicated to his father, who, in spite of showing many faces of cruelty, had exposed Suman to the wide spectrum of music via a borrowed gramophone player. With the lines \u2018\u09a6\u09ae \u09ab\u09c1\u09b0\u09be\u09a8\u09cb\u00a0\u0995\u09b2\u09c7\u09b0 \u0997\u09be\u09a8\u09c7\u2019 (On the slowing down gramophone), which are a part of the song,\u00a0Suman pays homage to all the composers and singers who have shaped his musical sensibility. He ends by paying homage to his father who brought these songs to him, who has been his lifelong friend, but now has grown old, leaving him behind.<\/p>\n

The day his father died Suman went for a show that had been sold out and could not be cancelled. At the end of the show he said, \u201cI have been singing for three hours. None of you told me \u2018You have fulfilled your professional commitment. Now go home and perform the last rites of your father.\u2019\u201d<\/p>\n

Death is a recurring motif in Bare Voice<\/em>. The film begins with Suman\u2019s near encounter with death, followed by his song \u2018\u099c\u09be\u09a4\u09bf\u09b8\u09cd\u09ae\u09b0\u2019 where he sings<\/p>\n

\u0985\u09ae\u09b0\u09a4\u09cd\u09ac\u09c7\u09b0 \u09aa\u09cd\u09b0\u09a4\u09cd\u09af\u09be\u09b6\u09be \u09a8\u09c7\u0987 \u09a8\u09c7\u0987 \u0995\u09cb\u09a8\u09cb \u09a6\u09be\u09ac\u09bf \u09a6\u09be\u0993\u09df\u09be
\n\u098f\u0987 \u09a8\u09b6\u09cd\u09ac\u09b0 \u099c\u09c0\u09ac\u09a8\u09c7\u09b0 \u09ae\u09be\u09a8\u09c7 \u09b6\u09c1\u09a7\u09c1 \u09a4\u09cb\u09ae\u09be\u0995\u09c7\u0987 \u099a\u09be\u0993\u09df\u09be<\/p>\n

\u2026\u2026<\/p>\n

\u0986\u0997\u09c7\u0993 \u09ae\u09b0\u09c7\u099b\u09bf \u0986\u09ac\u09be\u09b0 \u09ae\u09b0\u09ac\u09cb \u09aa\u09cd\u09b0\u09c7\u09ae\u09c7\u09b0 \u09a6\u09bf\u09ac\u09cd\u09af\u09bf \u09a6\u09bf\u09df\u09c7<\/p>\n

(I do not hope for immortality; I have no tall claims
\nIn my mortal life my only claim is You<\/p>\n

\u2026\u2026<\/p>\n

I have died many deaths; I will die again for You)<\/p>\n

\"Suman

Suman at the prime of his career<\/p><\/div>\n

 <\/p>\n

At the end of 2 hours and 15 minutes it is time for Suman to sing \u2018\u0998\u09c1\u09ae\u09be\u0993 \u09ac\u09be\u0989\u09a3\u09cd\u09a1\u09c1\u09b2\u09c7 \u0998\u09c1\u09ae\u09be\u0993 \u098f\u09ac\u09be\u09b0\u2019\u00a0(Time for you to sleep, O vagabond). The screen goes black. We hear Suman\u2019s voice recalling how when he was at death\u2019s door, he had a vision of Vivekananda standing erect. Sudipto Chatterjee had said earlier in the film \u201cA genius does not die\u201d.<\/p>\n

Jaideep Varma first met Suman on 17 January 2024. What was supposed to be an hour-long meeting, lasted six hours. \u201cDo what you plan to do fast. Am not there for long\u201d were his parting words. Suman borrowed three weeks\u2019 time to recover. Shooting began on 20 April 2024. The core shooting was wrapped up in two weeks. The rest of the effort went in procuring archival footage, photographs, and songs. Sa Re Ga Ma (HMV) came forward and offered the original tracks of Suman\u2019s songs to Varma against the credit of Sa Re Ga Ma as co-producer of the film. Sudipto Chatterjee offered the rushes of his film Free to Sing<\/em> made in 1996. Jaideep painstakingly digitized the footage from analogue tapes that had visuals of Suman\u2019s stage performances and Pete Seger\u2019s 1996 visit to Calcutta.<\/p>\n

Editing a documentary film is at times trickier than editing a pre-scripted fiction film. A documentary editor had to spend endless hours groping for the juxtapositions that would complete the story or throw new light to the story. He has to churn the amorphous mass of the rushes to look for the strands that would complete the narrative tapestry. At last, a radiant bird comes to life, it spreads its wings and takes a flight. The wings of the bird should be light for it to fly high as the dead weight of avoidable footage should be taken off its wings.<\/p>\n

Suman has been a phenomenon in his lifetime. He is instrumental in initiating a whole new genre called \u2018\u099c\u09c0\u09ac\u09a8\u09ae\u09c1\u0996\u09c0 \u0997\u09be\u09a8\u2019\u00a0or \u2018Songs of Life\u2019. Bare Voice <\/em>captures this expanse. When the credits begin to roll, Suman emerges as a vulnerable yet contended man whose mind is still ticking with new ideas. He is a sum total of all his songs and more.<\/p>\n

Bare Voice<\/em> is a film that would draw in fans of Suman, followers of contemporary Bengali music, cultural historians and scholars of modern Bengali language. Bare Voice<\/em> will introduce to the music lovers of the world, the phenomenon called Suman. It is a film worth watching again and again and discovering something new in every viewing.<\/p>\n